Aller au contenu principal
En direct Manifestation « contre le racisme anti-blancs » à Angers : en dépit de l’interdiction, les néofascistes déroulent leur haine
635 nouveau 1 angles 8,911 dossiers
Dimanche 22 novembre 2026 0
Traduit par NobuAI Les articles non francophones sont affichés en français quand une traduction NobuAI est disponible. Traductions NobuAI disponibles.
UK mathematician debunks myth around Parthenon’s optical illusions
Article · Lu chez The Guardian · il y a 2 mois

UK mathematician debunks myth around Parthenon’s optical illusions

Source The Guardian GB · EN
Gauche Associatif
Crédibilité de la source 85/100
Aperçu Résumé multi-sources à venir si d'autres couvertures rejoignent cette histoire.

Study challenges belief that temple’s curves were designed to correct optical illusions that would have ruined its clean linesA mathematician has uncovered what may be one of the longest-running myths in history after studying optical illusions and the Parthen...

Texte intégral

Lire l'article complet dans GrimbaNews

618 mots

A mathematician has uncovered what may be one of the longest-running myths in history after studying optical illusions and the Parthenon, the famed Greek temple that overlooks Athens.

Scholars have marvelled at the building on the Acropolis hill for more than 2,000 years and heaped praise on its architects for their clever use of geometry. Its subtle curves are said to correct optical illusions that would have otherwise ruined the Parthenon’s clean lines.

But after a detailed investigation, and a flurry of mathematical modelling, Prof Alain Goriely at the University of Oxford has reached an awkward conclusion. The optical illusions the curves are meant to fix are either nonsense or practically imperceptible. In short, the illusions are themselves an illusion.

In his study, Goriely traces the myth back to the 1st-century Roman architect and engineer Vitruvius who wrote about the Parthenon 400 years after its construction. His account found its way into architectural books and became established fact. Today’s AI chatbots still churn out the tale. “I do think it might be the oldest myth that we have,” Goriely said, “apart from religion.”

A common claim that the mathematician challenges concerns the Parthenon’s base or stylobate. Measurements show the sides of the base are not horizontal but form a gentle arc that rises 6cm in the centre. According to Vitruvius, this corrects an illusion that would make the base appear to sag in the middle.

The sagging effect has been attributed to two proposed tricks of the light. The first states that long horizontal lines simply seem to slump in the middle, but Goriely found no evidence for this.

The second suggests that the Parthenon’s marble columns create the illusion. This is based on the Hering illusion where parallel lines on a 2D sheet can look bowed when other lines intersect them. But the Hering illusion is strongest when the intersecting lines are at acute angles. The columns at the Parthenon are too vertical to produce the illusion, and there is no proof it even works in 3D, Goriely said.

Another claim is that the bulges in the Parthenon’s columns – a curvature called entasis – corrects an optical illusion that would make them look too narrow in the middle. Again, Goriely found no evidence for the illusion. Moreover, the columns at the Parthenon bulge by a mere 18mm, which is barely perceptible at typical viewing distances.

Goriely, who assesses and dismisses other supposed “optical corrections” in his paper concedes he “fell into a bit of a rabbit hole” pulling all the evidence together. He suspects the Parthenon’s architects had other reasons for the architectural features.

The curve of the base may have prevented rain puddles forming and curved columns might simply have felt more organic and visually pleasing to the ancient Greeks, he writes in Royal Society Open Science.

It is unclear why the myth has endured for so long, but Goriely suspects that the perception of ancient Greece as a supremely knowledgeable and ingenious civilisation is partly to blame.

Unusually for an academic study, Goriely ends his paper by inviting readers to put it down and take a walk in a city. “Trust your own eyes, question what you see and decide for yourself whether the theory of optical corrections holds up,” he writes.

Frank Salmon, professor of the history of classical architecture at the University of Cambridge, said: “Some experts have long been cautious of Vitruvius’s explanations, recognising the risks inherent in using his text as a sort of bible to explain architectural practices in Greece centuries before his time, but also the loss of the many Greek texts about their temple architecture he claimed to have read when preparing his own.”

Source originale : The Guardian ↗

Partager cette histoire

Envoyez le dossier, pas seulement un titre isolé.

Twitter Bluesky
Partager :
System Admin

Laisser un commentaire

Votre adresse e-mail ne sera pas publiée. Les champs obligatoires sont marqués *

Your experience on this site will be improved by allowing cookies.