Aller au contenu principal
En direct Manifestation « contre le racisme anti-blancs » à Angers : en dépit de l’interdiction, les néofascistes déroulent leur haine
635 nouveau 1 angles 8,911 dossiers
Dimanche 22 novembre 2026 0
Traduit par NobuAI Les articles non francophones sont affichés en français quand une traduction NobuAI est disponible. Traductions NobuAI disponibles.
What happens if a mistrial is declared in Lindsay Clancy case?
Histoire · Lu d'abord chez BBC · 25 couvertures · Mis à jour il y a 1 mois

What happens if a mistrial is declared in Lindsay Clancy case?

Synthèse multi-sources ▾ cliquer pour masquer
  • Prosecutors could seek a new trial in the case of the US mother charged with murdering her three children in 2023. — BBC
  • On Thursday, Justice William F. — Daily Mail
  • Clancy’s attorneys say a mistrial shouldn’t have been declared and a retrial would result in double jeopardyLindsay Clancy returned to court on Tuesday, as her lawyers sought to head off a retrial by having a judge find... — The Guardian
  • L'ex-mari d'une mère américaine accusée du meurtre de leurs trois enfants a déclaré qu'il aurait été « rongé de l'intérieur pour toujours » s'il ne lui avait pas pardonné. — BBC
  • Judge Judy Sheindlin weighed in Thursday on the closely watched Lindsay Clancy murder case following its mistrial, warning there could be a "danger" in prosecutors deciding not to retry the Massachusetts mother accused o... — Fox News

Première phrase de chaque source · résumé NobuAI à venir.

Comparaison de cadrage Comment chaque côté du spectre couvre la même histoire.
Côté gauche 1 source
  • Clancy’s attorneys say a mistrial shouldn’t have been declared and a retrial would result in double jeopardyLindsay Clancy returned to court on Tuesday, as her lawyers sought to head off a retrial by having a judge find...

    — The Guardian
Côté centre 2 sources
  • Prosecutors could seek a new trial in the case of the US mother charged with murdering her three children in 2023.

    — BBC
  • L'ex-mari d'une mère américaine accusée du meurtre de leurs trois enfants a déclaré qu'il aurait été « rongé de l'intérieur pour toujours » s'il ne lui avait pas pardonné.

    — BBC
Côté droit 2 sources
  • On Thursday, Justice William F.

    — Daily Mail
  • Judge Judy Sheindlin weighed in Thursday on the closely watched Lindsay Clancy murder case following its mistrial, warning there could be a "danger" in prosecutors deciding not to retry the Massachusetts mother accused o...

    — Fox News

Synthèse extractive multi-sources · vérification éditoriale en bouclage · NobuAI complète l'analyse dès qu'assez de sources couvrent l'histoire.

Texte intégral

Lire l'article complet dans GrimbaNews

794 mots
What happens if a mistrial is declared in Lindsay Clancy case?Figure caption,

Watch moment judge in Clancy case says a mistrial likely

ByMadeline Halpert and Sareen Habeshian
  • Published40 minutes ago

After a week of mulling Lindsay Clancy's fate, jurors remained deadlocked in the case of the US mother accused of murdering her three young children.

Judge William Sullivan has yet to formally declare a mistrial because Clancy's lawyer Kevin Reddington has asked for an hour to file an emergency appeal.

But Sullivan's indication that he will declare a mistrial opens the door to a host of possibilities about what happens next.

Clancy, who faced three counts of first-degree murder, does not deny killing her children in 2023 but pleaded not guilty, with her lawyers arguing she was suffering from postpartum psychosis and should not be held criminally responsible.

The prosecution said she made a calculated, intentional decision to kill them.

What is a mistrial?

Under US law, the jury must unanimously reach a conclusion "beyond a reasonable doubt". If they cannot, the judge can call a mistrial, which ends the trial with no verdict.

Jurors in Clancy's trial have been deadlocked for days, and have told the judge three times that they are unable to come to a unanimous decision.

Sullivan, who is overseeing the trial, previously urged them to continue deliberating until there is no possible chance of a decision.

In a last-ditch effort he issued additional instructions, known as a Tuey-Rodriguez charge in the state, encouraging the panel to consider all perspectives and ensuring jurors were questioning and examining their own views in the case.

The jury continued to indicate they could not come to a consensus, leading the judge to say he had no choice but to declare a mistrial.

This does not mean prosecutors have proven their case, nor does it mean the defendant is not guilty.

If a mistrial is formally declared on Friday, the prosecution could either refile and restart with a new jury or negotiate a plea agreement.

Alternatively, prosecutors could dismiss the charges altogether.

Figure caption,

Watch: BBC's Ione Wells explains how the Lindsay Clancy trial could end

Could Lindsay Clancy go free?

Not immediately. In the event of a mistrial, Clancy would remain held under the same murder charges in the mental health facility where she is currently housed as lawyers weigh their next steps.

If a new trial is planned, Clancy will remain in that facility until it begins - though her lawyers could ask for a review of her bail situation, said Heather Cucolo, a New York Law School professor and expert in mental health law.

Even as a new trial is being prepared, prosecutors could still negotiate with Clancy's team over a plea agreement, Cucolo said.

Will prosecutors try for a new trial?

In serious felony cases like these, prosecutors often ask for a retrial.

If they do, the jury selection process will take place once again and a new trial will be scheduled with a new set of jurors.

The time it could take to schedule another trial will depend on factors including the court schedule, any legal requests either side may file, and how long it may take to line up expert witnesses.

The six-week trial in Massachusetts captured significant public interest, with crowds sometimes gathering outside.

"A case like this that obviously has been so high profile, and there is so much of an emotional response to this to the facts of this case, I think it's very likely that the prosecutor will ask for a retrial," Cucolo said.

Image source, Patti Anne PhotographyImage caption,

Clancy's children Cora (left), eight-month-old Callan (centre) and three-year-old Dawson

What caused the jury deadlock?

That is unclear, but it's been a complex case with each side using a huge amount of expert testimony.

The identities of the nine women and three men on the jury has not been made public, and the judge banned any photographing or filming of them to retain their anonymity.

But once the case is over, a juror can choose whether or not to speak publicly about the case and their deliberations.

Following other high-profile trials, jurors have in some instances come forward to discuss the case, even writing books or doing media interviews.

So while it remains unknown to the public what has gone on behind closed doors, more could be revealed in the coming days or weeks.

If you are suffering distress or despair and need support, you could speak to a health professional, or an organisation that offers support. Details of help available in many countries can be found at Befrienders Worldwide. www.befrienders.org.

In the UK a list of organisations that can help is available at bbc.co.uk/actionline

More on this story

Source originale : BBC ↗

Partager cette histoire

Envoyez le dossier, pas seulement un titre isolé.

Twitter Bluesky
Provenance des sources

Matrice des angles

Chaque source est reliée à son pays d’origine, son camp éditorial et l’extrait qui soutient le cadrage.

Voir le dossier
Sources 7
Camp dominant Droite · 43%
Équilibre 67%
Origine dominante Europe
Europe Royaume-Uni (GB)
3 sources Dominant: Gauche · 33%
Amériques États-Unis (US)
2 sources Dominant: Droite · 100%
International Qatar (QA)
1 source Dominant: Gauche · 100%
Amériques Canada (CA)
1 source Dominant: Centre · 100%
Gauche · 2 Centre · 2 Droite · 3
The Guardian Gauche

Lindsay Clancy returns to court after Massachusetts murder case mistrial

Clancy’s attorneys say a mistrial shouldn’t have been declared and a retrial would result in double jeopardyLindsay Clancy returned to court on Tuesday, as her lawyers so...

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 1 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
The Guardian Gauche

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer urges Trump to consider pardon after mistrial

Attorney hopes Trump would ‘consider a pardon’ given ‘the type of person she is’ and ‘what she has been through’Murder trial ends in dramatic deadlock – what comes nextTh...

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
Al Jazeera English Gauche

Judge declares mistrial in Lindsay Clancy children’s murder case

Lindsay Clancy’s high-profile trial for the murder of her three children has ended in a mistrial.

International · Qatar (QA) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
The Guardian Gauche

Lindsay Clancy judge declares mistrial – what happens next?

The case essentially goes back to the same status as before the trial began, and prosecutors have to decide whether to try againFull report: Judge declares mistrial in Li...

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
The Guardian Gauche

Judge set to declare mistrial in Lindsay Clancy case after jury deadlocked again

Defense lawyer has asked for an hour to request emergency stay after jury deadlocked for third timeLindsay Clancy murder trial: live updatesThe judge in the trial of Lind...

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
The Guardian Gauche

Lindsay Clancy murder trial: judge set to call mistrial after jury deadlocks – live updates

Jury returns to tell judge for a third time it cannot reach a verdict in case of Massachusetts woman who killed her childrenThis dramatic turn of events, as the judge was...

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
The Guardian Gauche

Deadlocked jury in Lindsay Clancy trial resumes deliberations after dispute

Jury starts seven day of deliberations after foreperson told judge juror won’t follow instruction about reasonable doubtThe deadlocked jury in the Lindsay Clancy trial st...

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
The Guardian Gauche

Lindsay Clancy jury sent home again without verdict in murder trial

Deadlocked jurors to return on Friday to see if they can reach a decision after dramatic day of deliberationsThe deadlocked jury in the Lindsay Clancy trial went home wit...

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
BBC Centre

Regarder : Patrick Clancy dit qu'il pardonne à son ex-femme, Lindsay

L'ex-mari d'une mère américaine accusée du meurtre de leurs trois enfants a déclaré qu'il aurait été « rongé de l'intérieur pour toujours » s'il ne lui avait pas pardonné...

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
BBC Centre

'Emotional rollercoaster' - Lindsay Clancy jurors speak out on what led to mistrial

The three jurors said after 40 hours, a lone male juror wouldn't agree with the rest of the panel to find Clancy not guilty by reason of insanity.

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
BBC Centre

Lindsay Clancy's lawyer hopes for deal with prosecutors after mistrial

Kevin Reddington also asked Trump to pardon Clancy a pardon, during his appearance on Good Morning America.

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
BBC Centre

Americanswers… on 5 Live! Why is Lindsay Clancy’s mistrial dividing America?

And will Trump succeed in limiting mail-in voting before the midterms?

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
BBC Centre

Le procès a été déclaré nul dans l'affaire du meurtre de Lindsay Clancy, après l'impasse du jury

L'annulation du procès laisse désormais l'affaire du meurtre - et l'avenir de Clancy - dans l'incertitude quant à savoir si elle sera tenue pénalement responsable de la m...

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
BBC Centre

Watch: What is a mistrial and what does it mean for Lindsay Clancy?

The BBC's Ione Wells explains what could happen now as the case of the US mother accused of murdering her three children ends in no verdict.

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
BBC Centre

What happens if a mistrial is declared in Lindsay Clancy case?

Prosecutors could seek a new trial in the case of the US mother charged with murdering her three children in 2023.

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
Global News Centre

Judge says he’ll declare mistrial in Lindsay Clancy case after jury cannot reach a verdict

The judge in the Lindsay Clancy case said he was going to declare a mistrial on Friday before giving her defense attorney an hour to appeal.

Amériques · Canada (CA) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
BBC Centre

Watch: Jury still unable to reach unanimous decision in Lindsay Clancy case

For a second time in two days, jurors told the judge they could not agree on a verdict in the murder trial.

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
Daily Mail Droite

Lindsay Clancy loses daring bid to have her found not guilty of murdering her three children after mistrial

On Thursday, Justice William F. Sullivan denied the motion writing that the evidence 'was sufficient to have satisfied any rational trier of fact beyond a reasonable doub...

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 1 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
Fox News Droite

Judge Judy warns of 'danger' if prosecutors don't retry Lindsay Clancy after murder trial ends in mistrial

Judge Judy Sheindlin weighed in Thursday on the closely watched Lindsay Clancy murder case following its mistrial, warning there could be a "danger" in prosecutors decidi...

Amériques · États-Unis (US) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
Fox News Droite

Lindsay Clancy's lawyer reveals post-mistrial strategy as retrial looms

Kevin Reddington is laying out an aggressive, multi-pronged strategy to keep Lindsay Clancy from facing another jury — and, ultimately, from going to prison — as prosecut...

Amériques · États-Unis (US) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
Breitbart News Droite

Lindsay Clancy Jurors Tell on Themselves After Mistrial

Jurors in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial appeared to admit that nurses on the panel used their own medical knowledge to help interpret toxicology evidence during deliber...

Amériques · États-Unis (US) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
Fox News Droite

Lindsay Clancy mistrial declared after jury deadlocks in killings of her three children

Judge William Sullivan declared a mistrial Friday in Lindsay Clancy’s murder case after jurors said they were unable to reach a unanimous verdict in the killings of her t...

Amériques · États-Unis (US) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
Daily Mail Droite

Lindsay Clancy judge declares a MISTRIAL after case divided the world with its difficult questions about postpartum mental health

The almost incomprehensible violence and the difficult questions the case raised about postpartum mental health made headlines across the world and sparked endless online...

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
Breitbart News Droite

Nolte: Mistrial On Hold as Defense Seeks to Boot Hold-Out Juror in Lindsay Clancy Case

The jury in the Lindsay Clancy triple-murder case is officially hung, and on Friday the judge declared a mistrial. The post Nolte: Mistrial On Hold as Defense Seeks to Bo...

Amériques · États-Unis (US) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier
Daily Mail Droite

Deadlocked Lindsay Clancy jury sent home for the night to sleep on verdict after failing to reach unanimous decision

The jury in Lindsay Clancy's murder trial told the judge they could not come to an unanimous decision after five days of deliberations.

Europe · Royaume-Uni (GB) il y a 2 mois Ouvrir dans le dossier

25 articles

Lu chez Daily Mail The Guardian BBC Fox News Breitbart News Al Jazeera English Global News
Trier
Your experience on this site will be improved by allowing cookies.